Catch ’Em Doing It Right, Then Blow Them Away
Let’s get one thing straight. Most managers are world-class at catching people doing something wrong. Missed the number? Late on the report? Dropped the ball with a client? We’re all over it.
Winning leaders flip the script.
Ken Blanchard nailed it decades ago in The One-Minute Manager. Catch people doing something right. Now let’s put some rocket fuel on that idea. Catch them doing it right, and back it up with a surprise bonus.
Not a scheduled bonus. Not an “everybody gets one” bonus. A surprise.
Why surprise wins
Expected rewards turn into entitlements fast. Give the same bonus every December, it’s not a reward. It becomes an expected part of compensation. It’s part of the salary, and the moment you pull it, you’ve created a morale problem.
Worse yet, what if you have a great year and go big on the Holiday bonus payout, what’s expected next year, and the year after that?
A surprise bonus works differently. It isn’t on the budget as a recurring line item, so you don’t incur expense creep. It isn’t a promise, so there’s no entitlement. And because nobody sees it coming, people remember it, possibly for years depending on how big or how special you go with personalization. They tell their spouse about it, they tell their friends, and they may also tell the next great recruit you’re trying to land.
What it looks like
It doesn’t have to be big. It must be right.
- Cash in an envelope, handed over in person, with a sentence on exactly what they did.
- A (significant) gift certificate to the restaurant they keep talking about or their favorite place to celebrate a life event.
- Tickets to see their team play. Consider what their spouse, significant other, children, or grandchildren would deem as being super special!
- Something for their family. A weekend getaway, a dinner out with their spouse, a gift for the kids.
That last one deserves attention. When you recognize the people who support your teammate at home, the ones who put up with the late nights and the travel, you’ve won the household. People don’t just stay with a company like that. They recruit for it.
Doing it right
Be specific. “Great job” could be perceived as being low impact. How about “The way you turned around the Henderson account last Tuesday kept a six-figure client in the building” is a message.
Be timely. Recognition loses its punch fast, so act quickly, minutes, hours, days.
Make it public when it fits and private when it doesn’t. Know your people.
Build the culture
Hyper-growth companies don’t run on compensation plans alone. They run on people who know their effort is seen. Catch them doing it right, back it up, and watch for the behavior you rewarded. Hopefully, it will show up repeatedly.
That’s how you build a winning team. Keep in mind that culture is caught, not taught!
PS: Make it count. The best surprise bonuses are personal. A fly-fishing guide day means nothing to someone who hates the outdoors, and season tickets mean nothing to someone who doesn’t follow the sport. Know your teammate well enough that the reward says I see you, not just thanks.